CCAC revote reverses design recommendation for 2015 March of Dimes silver dollar obverse

Recommendation features profiles of FDR, Dr. Salk
By Paul Gilkes , Coin World
Published : 05/21/14
Text Size

The proposed design being recommended by the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee for the obverse of the 2015 March of Dimes commemorative silver dollar is not the original top vote-getter among the designs reviewed May 19 in Philadelphia.

The design being recommended depicts jugate portraits facing right of President Franklin D. Roosevelt and Dr. Jonas Salk. The design received the CCAC’s final recommendation after a second round of balloting was conducted among the top two design contenders.

The design receiving the highest number of votes during the initial voting, and one more than the second-place finisher eventually given the nod, features Dr. Jonas Salk extracting the anti-poliomyelitis vaccine, as well as showing the double RNA helix and several 1946 Roosevelt dimes.

The CCAC’s recommended reverse design was inspired by the many success stories of the March of Dimes and is symbolic of a mother’s love.

The commemorative coin marks the 75th anniversary of the establishment of the March of Dimes Foundation and its fight against polio and other birth defects. President Roosevelt’s personal struggle with polio led to the establishment of the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis, eventually renamed the March of Dimes.

Dr. Salk discovered and developed the first successful inactivated polio vaccine, which was introduced in 1957.

CCAC members were presented with 22 proposed obverse and 18 reverse designs. Several of the proposed obverse and reverse designs were nearly identical except for their inscriptions. The list was significantly pared down before the CCAC individually scrutinized and discussed the remaining designs.

Before an in-depth design review began, CCAC Chairman Gary Marks withdrew designs from consideration if no interest was shown in them by CCAC members during a roll call of the individual designs.

Following the discussion by each of the 10 members present on their individual design preferences among the remaining designs, CCAC members were able to rank their choices based on the panel's voting system.

The design incorporating the Roosevelt dimes received 19 votes and the conjoined profiles of Roosevelt and Salk received 18. None of the other obverse designs being considered received sufficient votes to be reconsidered. A revote gave the nod to the Roosevelt-Salk design.

CCAC member Michael Bugeja had expressed his concerns that incorporating renditions of one or more Roosevelt dimes within a design would repeat the mandated mottoes. CCAC member Thomas, who is president of the Pennsylvania Association of Numismatists, suggested that the design bearing the jugate profiles of Roosevelt and Salk would have a better chance for the coin to sell out.

The enabling legislation, Public Law 112-209, authorizes the production and release combined in Proof and Uncirculated versions of 500,000 coins, each to include a $10 surcharge. Net surcharges, after the U.S. Mint recoups its production and distribution costs, are to be paid to the March of Dimes to help finance research, education and services aimed at improving the health of women, infants and children.

The Treasury secretary is also authorized to make bulk discounts of the coins available.

The CCAC's recommendations will be forwarded to the Treasury secretary to be considered along with the Commission of Fine Arts design recommendations before the Treasury secretary makes final approval.

Coin World will continue to publish updates as they become available.

You are signed in as:null
2 comments
anonymous
anonymous May 22, 2014 7:30 AM
It is not unusual for the CCAC to revote on top selections. In fact, we did this earlier on another selection. Our process allows for amendments and discussion, just as any Roberts Rules committee enjoys. Moreover, missing from this article is the recommendation that a silver dime and reverse-proof dime with a West Point mint mark be included in the marketing of this US Mint product.
anonymous
anonymous May 31, 2014 10:15 AM
I am glad to hear a request for a dime. Maybe we should have a circulation coin though something the lower income who gave so much could acquire.