Insights

Error coin specialist Fred Weinberg confirms ‘plain edge’ 2014 Coolidge Presidential dollar of Denver Mint

PCGS authenticates first known example lacking edge inscriptions
By , Coin World
Published : 06/06/14
Text Size

A circulation-quality 2014 Calvin Coolidge Presidential dollar missing its edge devices was reported May 30.

It is the first circulation-quality Presidential dollar since the 2012 Grover Cleveland, First Term coins from the Philadelphia Mint to have missing edge lettering reported, according to error specialist Fred Weinberg.

Rodney Levingston from South Park Coins in Forney, Texas, said May 30 that the 2014 Calvin Coolidge dollar missing its edge devices was found May 14 in a 25-coin roll of Denver Mint strikes specially wrapped on behalf of the U.S. Mint and sold to the public. 

Levingston said he discovered the error Calvin Coolidge dollar while filling an order requiring four of the 2014-D dollars. One of the dollars removed from the roll was missing its edge devices, Levingston said. The remaining coins in the roll all had their edge inscriptions.

Levingston’s discovery is now graded and encapsulated Mint State 65 by Professional Coin Grading Service.

Weinberg said the last Presidential dollars confirmed as missing their edge devices were 2012 Grover Cleveland, First Term strikes believed to be Philadelphia Mint products, removed from 100-coin numismatic product bags. Weinberg believes just eight to 10 of those Cleveland, First Term, Missing Edge Lettering Presidential dollars are known.

Prices for the various Presidential dollars missing the edge inscriptions vary widely (dependant on such factors as rarity and, maybe more importantly, current demand). The 2007 Washington coins (the most common one) are priced at well below $100. A 2013 auction by Ira and Larry Goldberg Auctioneers offering many different pieces saw some common pieces (for Martin Van Buren and James Madison) selling for less than $60. 

The results from the Goldberg auction also showed how much the market for some of the error coins has fallen as more examples are discovered. As noted in Coin World’s Nov. 11, 2013, Market Analysis: “The lot description for lot 1732, a 2007 Thomas Jefferson dollar graded PCGS Mint State 66, told a cautionary tale, noting that the issue is ‘Somewhat rare due to a large number of previous buyers who paid as much as $30,000 and now do not want to sell at a major loss.’ Estimated at $250 to $300, it realized $460.”

The Market Analysis added that in the same auction, “Rare edge inscription variants of the 2009-P Zachary Taylor, 2009-P John Tyler, 2009-P James K. Polk and 2010-P Millard Fillmore dollars brought the same $4,313 price.”

When introduced in 2007, the Presidential dollars bore the date, Mint mark, and the inscriptions IN GOD WE TRUST and E PLURIBUS UNUM on the edge rather than on the obverse or reverse faces. 

The edge inscriptions are applied after the coins are struck, in a separate production step. The edge inscription equipment was not integrated into the otherwise seamless production line at the Mint facilities until 2009. The separation of the edge inscription equipment in 2007 and 2008 helps account for the larger numbers of coins with plain edges from those two years.

You are signed in as:null

You are not allowed to post here, please sign in or join

1 comment
I recently purchased a 2012-D Chester Arthur NGC MS65 slabbed as "95% Missing Edge Lettering" & a 2012-P Grover Cleveland (2nd Term) NGC MS66 slabbed as "Missing Edge Lettering". This follows on the heels of the find & purchase of a 2008-D James Monroe NGC MS69 slabbed as "Missing Edge Lettering" & "Annual Dollar Set"...this coin is the Satin Finish version & may be the only slabbed M.E.L. coin attributed from the Annual Dollar Set. higgsgerald@yahoo.com or (208) 267-0999 to reply. All three of the above are unique at this point.