Errors and Varieties: Clipped discs can leave characteristic impressions in coins

Collectors' Clearinghouse column from the Aug. 25, 2014, issue of Coin World
By , Special to Coin World
Published : 08/12/14
Text Size

Ordinary indents and partial brockages are respectively generated by planchets and coins. These circular discs of metal naturally leave behind indentations with a smoothly curved, convex internal margin. The situation is quite different when the object involved is a clipped planchet or a coin struck on such a planchet.

The illustrated 2010 5-rupee coin from India was struck through a clipped planchet on its obverse face. In this case, the obstructing planchet had a curved clip, the most common kind. 

Since the obverse face of Indian coins is usually struck by the anvil die, it would appear that a clipped planchet was fed beneath a normal planchet represented by the illustrated example. Both planchets were struck fully within the collar. Had the bottom planchet not been clipped, this error would have been classified as an in-collar uniface strike.

A bonus feature is the presence of a dramatic extrusion strike. During the strike, coin metal bulged into the gap between the bottom planchet and the collar, simultaneously moving toward the anvil die and away from the hammer (reverse) die. The apex of the bulge contacted the anvil die, producing a small oval of die-struck design that includes portions of the letters IND. A deep, featureless pucker appears in the same location on the reverse face.

Not all coins struck through similarly clipped planchets will show an extrusion strike. A set of “Goldilocks” conditions must exist. The clip mustn’t be too large or too small, and the planchet mustn’t be too thick or too thin. At 6 grams, 23 millimeters wide, and 1.9 millimeters thick, this nickel-brass planchet is a much better candidate for an extrusion strike than the older copper-nickel planchet (1992 to 2004), which weighed a whopping 9 grams. 

Effective striking pressure (baseline ram pressure boosted by the double thickness involved) also must be just right. Too high and there’s no pucker — just a normal die-struck design. Too low and there’s no design on either face in the area of the normal planchet that is exposed by the clip.

Among domestic coins, fully centered indents from curved clip planchets have been observed among 5-cent coins and dimes.

I have also seen indents from curved clip planchets that were struck off-center. In these cases, one tip of the clipped planchet leaves behind a horn-shaped indentation.

A number of domestic cents are known that were indented by cents struck on bowtie clips composed of copper-nickel clad dime material. 

Any sort of clip can leave its impression in a coin. Shown here is the reverse of a 1998-D Washington quarter dollar that was struck though an elliptical copper-nickel clad layer. This layer had earlier separated from an elliptical clip quarter dollar blank or planchet and arrived in the striking chamber beneath a normal planchet (this coin). The design struck through the clad layer shows a uniform mushiness. Two thin crescents of normal, die-struck design can be seen above and below the shallow oval recess generated by the thin elliptical layer.

You are signed in as:null

You are not allowed to post here, please sign in or join

No comments yet