Five legendary baseball players have begun reviewing the semi-finalist designs for the 2014 National Baseball Hall of Fame commemorative coins.
The five judges are all members of the Major League Baseball’s Hall of Fame. They began deliberating June 5 on 24 designs that are in competition for use on the concave common obverse of the 2014 gold $5 half eagle, silver dollar and copper-nickel half dollar coins that will honor the Hall of Fame.
The semifinalist designs were posted online June 5 at batterup.challenge.gov/submissions. Twenty-two of the 24 designs were submitted with a thematic title, with one entry referencing just the United States Mint’s Baseball Coin Design Competition and another entry also including the name of the designer in addition to referencing the design contest.
All of the designs are posted with narratives from the individual designers explaining their reasoning for their individual designs. All of the designs include their date of submission.
The five Baseball Hall of Fame judges — Dave Winfield, Ozzie Smith, Brooks Robinson, Don Sutton and Joe Morgan, all former professional baseball players — began their review of the 24 designs June 5, according to Brad Horn, senior director of communications and education for the National Baseball Hall of Fame Museum in Cooperstown, N.Y.
Each of the five judges is conducting a separate review, independent of the others, and ranking the 24 designs in numerical order, according to Horn.
From those 24 designs will come the finalist designs, the number of which is yet to be determined, Horn said June 5.
Early design review process
The 24 semifinalist designs were pared down from 178 designs submitted between noon Eastern Daylight Time April 11 through 5 p.m. EDT May 11. The paring down was completed by a U.S. Mint cross-functional team.
Three United States Mint engravers and one Bureau of Engraving and Printing bank note designer first completed an artistic review of the submitted designs for the program.
The designs were further evaluated for appropriateness of the subject matter and coinability by both the National Baseball Hall of Fame and by several members of the Mint’s manufacturing and engraving staff, according to United States Mint spokesman Michael White.
Selecting the final design
The finalist designs will be evaluated by both the Commission of Fine Arts and Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee in July for their recommendations. The final adopted design will be selected by the Treasury secretary in consultation with the National Baseball Hall of Fame.
The Treasury secretary’s final selection is to be announced sometime in September along with the selection of the final design for the common reverse.
The winning designer of the Baseball Coin Design Competition is to receive compensation of no less than $5,000, according to provisions of the enabling legislation, Public Law Public Law 112-152, and will have his or her initials appear on the three commemorative coins along with those of the member of the U.S. Mint’s engraving staff assigned to sculpture the design.
The winning obverse design — which will appear concave on the three commemorative coin compositions and denominations — will be paired with the common reverse design.
The reverse design, according to provisions of Public Law Public Law 112-152, is to resemble the style of baseball used by Major League Baseball.
The CFA and CCAC have already reviewed and recommended proposed designs rendered by members of the U.S. Mint’s engraving staff and outside artists in the U.S. Mint’s Artistic Infusion Program.
Originally, just the half eagle and silver dollar were to be struck with a concave obverse and convex reverse, according to law provisions, but U.S. Mint officials subsequently decided to include the half dollar as well. ■